Take a peek under the news about the plot to return Jensen Huang to Nvidia and Anthropic’s high-stakes IPO tomorrow and you will see stories about people still trying to get a flight home, software bug-related outages at JPMorgan Chase (but apparently
Excellent piece about implementation decisions and the ed-tech marketplace. Thank you for writing. My anti-Canvas piece is not "blind" to this but rather I'm asking a different question. Your piece mentions the year 2011 four times! What is so special about 2011? Why, that's the birth-year of "learning outcomes" at scale, the year the Lumina Foundation released the beta version of the Degree Qualifications Profile (DQP) defining what students should know, in handy format for every faculty syllabus across the nation.
My point is that the Learning Outcomes era and the Learning Management Software era are intertwined. The battle between Blackboard and Canvas was a battle between guillotine manufacturers. They are both designed to cut the head off faculty and scale a kind of teaching and assessment based on learning outcomes rather than specific faculty expertise, essential to building the transfer industrial complex that is killing public higher education today.
AI has nothing to do with the current Learning Outcomes regime. AI could end it. That's my position. And this is the right debate to have !
Fair point, Hollis. And thanks as always for engaging. We agree that AI and the “disruptions” it brings may end the learning outcomes regime. In fact, I think that is one of many systems breaking down before our very eyes.
Where we differ (or maybe not?) is that I believe the guillotine manufacturers put themselves in charge of the race to make powerful AI models. Given what we see as those models are being used to wreck havoc on digital systems, that’s as dumb as putting tech startups in charge of virus research because we need to move as fast as possible to prevent the next pandemic.
Your point about 2011 makes me think about they ways that year marks a turn toward scaling up digital systems as quickly as possible without much consideration about the consequences.
Excellent piece about implementation decisions and the ed-tech marketplace. Thank you for writing. My anti-Canvas piece is not "blind" to this but rather I'm asking a different question. Your piece mentions the year 2011 four times! What is so special about 2011? Why, that's the birth-year of "learning outcomes" at scale, the year the Lumina Foundation released the beta version of the Degree Qualifications Profile (DQP) defining what students should know, in handy format for every faculty syllabus across the nation.
My point is that the Learning Outcomes era and the Learning Management Software era are intertwined. The battle between Blackboard and Canvas was a battle between guillotine manufacturers. They are both designed to cut the head off faculty and scale a kind of teaching and assessment based on learning outcomes rather than specific faculty expertise, essential to building the transfer industrial complex that is killing public higher education today.
AI has nothing to do with the current Learning Outcomes regime. AI could end it. That's my position. And this is the right debate to have !
Fair point, Hollis. And thanks as always for engaging. We agree that AI and the “disruptions” it brings may end the learning outcomes regime. In fact, I think that is one of many systems breaking down before our very eyes.
Where we differ (or maybe not?) is that I believe the guillotine manufacturers put themselves in charge of the race to make powerful AI models. Given what we see as those models are being used to wreck havoc on digital systems, that’s as dumb as putting tech startups in charge of virus research because we need to move as fast as possible to prevent the next pandemic.
Your point about 2011 makes me think about they ways that year marks a turn toward scaling up digital systems as quickly as possible without much consideration about the consequences.